AttomikATTOMIK
WORK / OTTERBEIN'S COOKIES
CLIENTACTIVE · SCALING

Revenue up 3.7x. Discounting down two thirds.

A cookie brand with no paid media or conversion infrastructure now runs paid media at 3.46x, discounting down two thirds.

RELATIONSHIPCLIENT
SCOPEDTC strategy, store build, paid media
PERIODMay 2026 to present
SYSTEMS[ SYSTEMS ]
A chocolate chip cookie being dunked into an Otterbein's Cookies mug on a sunlit kitchen counterOTTERBEIN'S COOKIES · PRODUCT[ SOURCE ]

BEFORE

No paid media. No conversion infrastructure. Discounts were eating 34.6% of gross sales, a third of the topline handed back at checkout, because price was the only lever anyone had.

The team was skeptical ecommerce could work for the category at all: cookies are low AOV, impulse, and expensive to ship.

WHAT ATTOMIK BUILT

01Pricing & OffersPricing architecture, bundle and offer structure, a P&L built around AOV and LTV.
02StoreA conversion-optimized store rebuilt for a category that hadn't run DTC before.
03RetentionWelcome, abandoned cart and review flows, plus subscription.
04Paid MediaWeekly creative briefing, audience testing, budget reallocated against real purchase data.
05AnalyticsFull instrumentation: the P&L and every media decision run on it.
Pricing & Offers
Store
Retention
Paid Media
Analytics

BEFORE

Paid mediaNone
Conversion infrastructureNone
Retention flowsNone
Discount rate34.6% of gross

THE ATTOMIK LAYER

PRICING + STORE + RETENTION + PAID MEDIA

AFTER

Paid media3.46x ROAS
Conversion infrastructureLive
Retention flowsWelcome · cart · reviews · subscription
Discount rate12.1% of gross
34.6%12.1%

DISCOUNT RATE, % OF GROSS

3.7xREVENUE SINCE APRILMonthly revenue, current vs. April baseline
34.6→12.1DISCOUNT RATE, % OF GROSSShare of gross sales given back as discounts
3.46xRETURN ON AD SPENDBlended ROAS, most recent month
3xSPEND INCREASE NEXT QUARTERPlanned paid media budget expansion
A stack of Otterbein's Cookies on a dark surface
OTTERBEIN'S COOKIES · PACKAGING
Otterbein's Cookies product photography
OTTERBEIN'S COOKIES · PRODUCT

WHERE IT STANDS

They're tripling paid media spend.

START A CONVERSATION

Bring us the problem. We'll build what changes the outcome.

Start a projectSee the work